Back to Blog
    Success Story

    From Faire to Shopify: Why Nature’s Scent Co. Built Its Own Wholesale Channel Without Shopify Plus

    Published Updated 8 min read
    Built for Shopify badgeOfficial Shopify Partner

    Nature’s Scent Co. built its brand on two platforms: Etsy for retail and Faire for wholesale. It's a 6+ year business based in Pennsylvania.

    Etsy helped Nature’s Scent Co. find retail customers, and Faire helped it find wholesale buyers. But running retail and wholesale on two different platforms brought its own challenges: operational, financial, and keeping the two consistent.

    After reaching a certain scale, Nature’s Scent Co. decided to consolidate both retail and wholesale business on one platform - Shopify. It went from Etsy and Faire to Shopify's built-in B2B, then tried several apps before settling on BMT B2B Wholesale Pricing. Here's why each move made sense, and what forced the next one.

    Why Nature’s Scent Co. Started on Faire

    When you're new to wholesale, the hard part is finding retailers who'll stock you. Faire does that for you. Retailers browse the marketplace and order, with no trade shows, sales reps or cold outreach. Faire also lets retailers pay on terms of up to 60 days, so they're more willing to try a new brand and place bigger first orders. You pay only when an order comes in, which makes Faire a cheap way to test whether wholesale demand exists.

    That's how Nature’s Scent Co. built its wholesale business: four to five regular wholesale accounts and more than $5,000 a month in recurring revenue.

    Why Faire Stopped Making Sense as the Whole Business

    Nothing broke on Faire. The reasons to leave came from the business working.

    The commission follows your best accounts

    Faire charges 15% plus $10 on a new retailer's first order, and 15% on every reorder from retailers who found you on Faire. A processing fee applies to every order on top of that. Reorders are where wholesale profit comes from, so the more a relationship grows, the more Faire takes. If every order came through the marketplace, that's $750 a month at $5,000. Faire Direct cuts the commission to 0% for retailers you bring in yourself, but not for reorders from retailers Faire found for you.

    The platform sits between you and your buyers

    Orders, messages and the storefront all run on Faire. The merchant wanted to run its own reorder campaigns, make offers to specific accounts and decide how its products appear.

    Faire decides the commission rate and the payment terms retailers get. The merchant wanted to offer 30-day terms to accounts with a steady record and ask new ones to pay upfront.

    Growth demands a unified platform for retail and wholesale

    A handful of steady accounts at $5,000+ a month was enough repeat business to build on.

    Each year, meeting growing demand with the same consistency across two platforms got harder. Nature’s Scent Co. also had full visibility over its supply chain and had worked out how to offer customers better prices at a lower cost. Marketplace fees stood in the way: Faire takes 15% of marketplace orders and Etsy around 10% of each sale, in return for helping brands build a steady business. So Nature’s Scent Co. decided to move to Shopify, stop paying commission on orders it could take directly, and pass better pricing on to its customers.

    So the plan was one Shopify store: retail shoppers buy at retail prices, approved wholesale buyers log in and buy on their own terms, from the same products and inventory.

    Why Native B2B Came First, and Where It Stopped

    After paying marketplace fees, the first option was the one already inside Shopify. Basic, Grow and Advanced include B2B features at no extra cost: company profiles, payment terms, volume pricing and B2B catalogs. For one wholesale price for everyone, that's often enough. This merchant needed more.

    Three catalogs weren't enough

    Plans below Plus allow three active B2B catalogs. The merchant already had more wholesale accounts on their own deals than that, with more coming through the website.

    Shopify Plus removes the limit, but it starts at $2,300 a month on a three-year term. That's 46% of $5,000 in wholesale revenue, and three times what Faire's commission would cost.

    The structure suits larger buyers

    Native B2B organizes each buyer as a company with locations, and prices them through catalogs. That works for a buyer with many stores. A short list of wholesale accounts, each with its own deal, fits a simpler setup: a customer, a tag, and the rules that tag unlocks.

    Legacy B2B Wholesale Apps: Good on Paper, Not in Practice

    Nature’s Scent Co. tried several longer-established wholesale apps with higher review counts and didn’t find one worth the money. In the merchant’s words, they were “too much money and too confusing to navigate.”

    Many of them also need two or three separate apps to cover everything a wholesale business needs.

    How BMT B2B Wholesale Pricing Handled the Seven Requirements

    Nature’s Scent Co. didn’t want to change Shopify plans or rebuild how it sold. It needed a layer on its existing store that could handle each wholesale account’s deal on its own terms.

    Here’s what that took, and how BMT covered each part.

    A price for each wholesale account

    One account gets 10% off, another has fixed prices on specific products, and a larger one gets volume pricing. BMT allows unlimited pricing rules by customer tag, with no catalog limit.

    Hide products and variants

    Account 1 buys products A, B and C, while account 2 buys B, C and D, and some variants are reserved for specific accounts. BMT's page locks show products, collections and even single variants only to buyers with the right tag.

    Shipping by Wholesale Group

    Negotiated freight rates and free-shipping thresholds are set as shipping methods for each customer group, so they apply at checkout.

    An application flow to replace Faire's discovery

    Buyers apply on the website and you review them. Approval unlocks wholesale access, which turns the website into the merchant's source of new wholesale accounts.

    Tags instead of a new customer structure

    BMT reads existing Shopify tags. For example, Distributor gets distributor pricing, Wholesale gets standard pricing, and VIP Wholesale gets negotiated prices and its own shipping.

    Net terms only for buyers who've earned them

    Net 15, 30 or 60 by customer group, plus draft orders, so trusted accounts pay later and new ones pay upfront.

    Retail and wholesale from one store

    Shoppers see retail prices. Wholesale buyers log in and see their own products, prices, shipping and payment terms.

    All seven run on BMT's Advanced plan at $29.99 a month, on top of the merchant's existing Shopify plan. Paid plans come with a 60-day free trial.

    What Each Option Costs at $5,000 a Month

    The cost difference is what made the decision clear. Here’s what each route would cost a business at this merchant’s size:

    Option

    Monthly cost

    Share of $5,000

    Every order through Faire's marketplace

    About $750 in commission, plus processing fees

    15% or more

    Shopify Plus for a catalog per wholesale

    From $2,300 (replaces your current plan)

    46%

    BMT Advanced on the existing Shopify plan

    $29.99

    0.6%

    Shopify Native B2B vs BMT B2B Wholesale Pricing for This Merchant

    Native B2B covers a lot of the same ground. The difference shows up in how far each one goes without Shopify Plus:

    Requirement

    Shopify native B2B (below Plus)

    BMT B2B Wholesale Pricing

    Separate prices for each wholesale account

    Up to 3 catalogs

    Unlimited pricing rules

    Hide products and variants by account

    Only within up to 3 catalogs

    Page locks by tag

    Shipping by wholesale group

    Not by customer group without another app

    Shipping methods by customer group

    Wholesale application and approval

    Account requests through Shopify Forms

    Registration form and approval flow

    Net terms and draft orders

    Included on every plan

    Net 15, 30 or 60 by group, plus draft orders

    Shopify Plus needed

    For more than 3 catalogs

    No

    Faire Didn't Go Away

    The merchant kept its Faire account, because Faire still puts the brand in front of retailers who'd never find it otherwise.

    The difference is that Faire is now one channel, not the whole business.

    New wholesale applications come through the merchant's own website, where it sets the prices, terms and shipping, and keeps the margin.

    Is This Path Right for You?

    You're in a similar spot if you're nodding at most of these:

    • "My reorders pay a commission I'd rather keep."
    • "I have more wholesale accounts on their own deals than three catalogs can hold."
    • "I want to choose which wholesale accounts see which products, and who gets net terms."
    • "I want wholesale and retail in one Shopify store, without paying for Plus while reducing operational overheads."

    You don't have to choose between Faire and your own store. Keep Faire for finding retailers, and run the ones who come through your website on Shopify with BMT. Try it free for 60 days.

    Where Nature’s Scent Co. Is Now

    After a lot of trial and error, the merchant now runs retail and wholesale on Shopify with BMT B2B Wholesale Pricing, and is very happy with the decision.

    Nature’s Scent Co. five-star review of BMT B2B Wholesale Pricing, praising tailored pricing, shipping rules, affordability and customer service

    Set it up in your store

    Step-by-step guides for the features covered above.

    Browse all setup guides

    Ready to grow your wholesale business?

    Install on Shopify